---
title: 'Philosophy and the Proletariat'
url: 'https://www.counterattackjournal.org/blog/mehring-philosophy_and_the_proletariat'
markdown: 'https://www.counterattackjournal.org/blog/mehring-philosophy_and_the_proletariat.md'
date: '2026-11-19'
description: 'Johann Gottlieb Fichte In 1844 Karl Marx wrote: “The emancipation of Germans is the emancipation of mankind. The head of this emancipation is philosophy; its heart is the proletariat.” In 1878 Engels wrote in agreement with Marx that the new advances of natural and historical science made a philosophy which stands over the other sciences superfluous “That which still survives of all earlier philosophy is the science of thought [...]—formal logic and dialectics. Everything else is subsumed in the positive science of Nature and history.” Between these two formulations lies a quarter century full of rich experiences for the working class. Insofar as it has attained class consciousness it has long ceased to see its savior in philosophy. But an irrepressible inclination to concern themselves with philosophy remains with them. Whoever has once taught at the Party School, knows well enough how alive this inclination is even in the younger generation. And insofar as they present an eloquent testimony about how our young workers strive to press into the depths and to experience for themselves what Kant, Hegel and Fichte, who Marx, Engels and Lassalle identified as their inheritance, have to say—in this regard, this urge is completely honorable. Philosophy and the Proletariat November 19, 2026 Franz Mehring Translated from: Sozialdemokratischen Korrespondenz, January 29th, 1914, Nr. 12. Collected Works, Volume 13. p 83-85. Orginal: web.archive.org In 1844 Karl Marx wrote: “The emancipation of Germans is the emancipation of mankind. The head of this emancipation is philosophy; its heart is the proletariat.'
taxonomy:
  category:
    - international
  tag:
    - translation
  featured:
    - feature
---

# Philosophy and the Proletariat

 November 19, 2026

### *Franz Mehring*

---

Translated from: 
*Sozialdemokratischen Korrespondenz, January 29th, 1914, Nr. 12.*
Collected Works, Volume 13. **p 83-85.**
Orginal: [web.archive.org](https://web.archive.org/web/20210428020331/https://sites.google.com/site/sozialistischeklassiker2punkt0/mehring/mehring-philosophie/franz-mehring-philosophie-und-proletariat)

---

In 1844 Karl Marx wrote: “The *emancipation of Germans* is the *emancipation of mankind*. The *head* of this emancipation is *philosophy*; its *heart* is the *proletariat*.”[1](#fn:f1) In 1878 Engels wrote in agreement with Marx that the new advances of natural and historical science made a philosophy which stands over the other sciences superfluous “That which still survives of all earlier philosophy is the science of thought \[...\]—formal logic and dialectics. Everything else is subsumed in the positive science of Nature and history.”[2](#fn:f2)

Between these two formulations lies a quarter century full of rich experiences for the working class. Insofar as it has attained class consciousness it has long ceased to see its savior in philosophy. But an irrepressible inclination to concern themselves with philosophy remains with them. Whoever has once taught at the Party School, knows well enough how alive this inclination is even in the younger generation. And insofar as they present an eloquent testimony about how our young workers strive to press into the depths and to experience for themselves what Kant, Hegel and Fichte, who Marx, Engels and Lassalle identified as their inheritance, have to say—in this regard, this urge is completely honorable.

But it also holds a danger in itself, in the face of which we all have reason to be weary, namely the danger of a mere verbal intoxication, which Lassalle already identified as a dangerous pitfall of every political movement. Precisely to a worker’s party is nothing more essential than clear and sharp thinking, and the more strongly the masses flow to its flag the more necessary it is. They must be on guard in the face of every mere buzzword, however dazzling it may be and however easy it may be on the ears; they must not defend the inheritance of bourgeois culture without summoning the reservations demanded by its class interests.

![Johann Gottlieb Fichte](https://www.counterattackjournal.org/images/7/6/4/4/b/7644b43f918e76031a3f0127b7878c74678d8983-023-fichtealsrednerandiedeutschenation-arthurkampf1915.jpeg "Fichte as speaker to the German nation")Fichte as speaker to the German nation

What suggests these considerations to us, is the 100th anniversary of the death of Johann Gottlieb Fichte which we have just celebrated and justly so. Among our classical philosophers, Fichte was the boldest and most revolutionary thinker, a complete man, upon whose authoritative life work every civilized person can only look up to with respect. But should we thereby forget that we are separated from Fichte by a world? Should we justify our demands with Fichte’s phrases, which have long proven themselves completely worthless in modern political struggles, already in the time, when the worthy Progress Party, claimed Fichte’s hundredth birthday celebration for itself? Or should we throw Fichte’s thoughts on the table, as political trump cards so to speak, certain that in the next minute they will be stung by our most venomous opponents using another thought of Fichte’s?

Let’s take Fichte’s “State of the Future”, his text on the “Closed Commercial State”, which a large liberal newspaper recently claimed makes Bebel’s “State of the Future” appear moderate and tame in comparison! Rarely has more absurd nonsense been printed. Fichte’s alleged revolutionary utopia is by all means nothing more than an impotent attempt to reduce the old Prussian state to the laws of bourgeois reason; today the most limited revolutionaries would flinch in shame before many of its demands.

Or take Fichte’s “Address to the German Nation”! If he says here that the Prussian collapse at Jena is to be explained through “that soft hand on the reins of the state, that with foreign words is called humanity, liberality, and popularity but is more correctly termed flabbiness and undignified conduct in the German language” then all our militarist Junkers from General Field Marshall Goltz to Lieutenant Forstner shout out: yes that’s precisely the case and only social democratic demagogues can deny it.[3](#fn:f3)

Or, how Fichte says in this Address, that a government can “also act without loyalty and forgetful of duty and honor abroad, only if domestically it has the courage to hold the reins of government with a stern hand, and to win a greater fear of itself”—can one wish for a stronger glorification of Bismarkism? Or Fichte’s blessing of a senseless war of annihilation waged by the Prussian bureaucracy in the Polish border territories, as he says in his Address: “once a people has ceased to rule itself, it is also just as responsible for abandoning its language and fusing with the conquerer?” and so on.

Do we want to somehow degrade Fichte here? Not even in the slightest. Even the greatest thinker cannot exceed the limits of his time, and if one studies Fichte’s life and times in depth, one finds that all the contradictions in his work, apparent and real in themselves, dissolve in the harmony of a great and strong character. And it is certainly also an honor of the working class to devote such historical study to our classical philosophy and to protect their memory from the vandalism of the bourgeoisie. But to use their individual slogans in everyday political struggles, which are not meant in our sense, and could not have been so meant, must lead to a flattening of the intellectual life of the Party.

What here is applied to the example of Fichte, because he is the closest to us in time, and the most seductive to us in deed, applies to all attempts to orient the proletarian class struggle to philosophical concepts and word games. They must be turned away at the threshold, as cobwebs which can only obscure the workers necessary understanding of nature and society.

Classical philosophy stands in the heaven of our intellectual world, like a distant constellation, the glaze of whose rays can delight our eyes or even dazzle them, but which can neither warm our blood nor strengthen our muscles. Our grapes are ripened only by the sun of labor and the humblest proletarian, who puts his entire strength in the economic and political liberation struggle of his class walks more surely along the path to human freedom that the greatest thinkers of our classical philosophy only sought by groping through thick fog and in the final conclusion still could not find.

---

1. Karl Marx: *Zur Kritik der Hegelschen Rechtsphilosophie*. In: Marx/Engels: Werke, Bd. 1, **p. 391.** [web.archive.org](https://web.archive.org/web/20210428020331/http://www.mlwerke.de/me/me01/me01_378.htm) [↩](#fnref1:f1)
2. Friedrich Engels: *Herrn Eugen Dührings Umwälzung der Wissenschaft* („Anti-Dühring‟). In: Ebenda, Bd. 20, **p. 24**. [web.archive.org](https://web.archive.org/web/20210428020331/http://www.mlwerke.de/me/me20/me20_016.htm#Kap_I) [↩](#fnref1:f2)
3. General field marshal von der Goltz, one of the most reactionary representatives of the Prussian-Junker military caste. Lieutenant Freiherr von Forstner was a young Prussian officer who caused the ‘Zabern Affair’ in the autumn of 1913. During a training session he insulted the Alsatians by calling them “Wackes” and promised every recruit who stabbed one a reward of 10 marks. This provocation unleashed an immense outrage among the Alsatians that led to protests against the military who responded with the imposition of a state of siege. Unlike virtually any other event in the years before world war one, the Zabern Affair exposed the true face of Prussian-German militarism. Lenin wrote at the time: “It is not Anarchy that has broken out in Zabern but the honest German order, the rule by saber of the semi-feudal Prussian landed gentry which has intensified and stepped out into the light.” (V. I. Lenin: *About German and the German worker’s movement*, Dietz Verlag, Berlin 1957, **p. 291**.) [↩](#fnref1:f3)

 ---

### SHARE

- [Facebook](https://www.facebook.com/sharer/sharer.php?u=https://www.counterattackjournal.org/blog/mehring-philosophy_and_the_proletariat "Philosophy and the Proletariat")
- [Twitter](http://twitter.com/home?status=Philosophy%20and%20the%20Proletariat-https://www.counterattackjournal.org/blog/mehring-philosophy_and_the_proletariat "Philosophy and the Proletariat")

   ---

---

## Navigation

- Parent: [Blog](https://www.counterattackjournal.org/index.md)
- Next: [The New Woman in Literature: On Olbracht&#8217;s Anna](https://www.counterattackjournal.org/blog/olbracht_anna_new_woman_in_literature.md)
